THE INSPIRATION PLACE PODCAST
Miriam Schulman: What galleries really look for when choosing artists. Today we’re breaking down the five criteria every gallery quietly evaluates, and how you can prepare yourself long before you send that portfolio email. Hey friend, it’s Miriam Schulman here, host of The Inspiration Place podcast. And today we’re answering one of the most searched for most anxiety producing questions in the entire art world. How do galleries actually choose artists? Or as people type into Google at 2 a.m., what galleries look for an artist? How do galleries select artists? Gallery representation requirements? Do galleries care about Instagram? Buckle up. You’re going to want to take notes. Most artists think galleries are looking for one thing art that they like. But actually that’s the last thing that on their list that they’re looking for and the least controllable. Good news is, the other four things are much more in your control. So today we’re breaking down the five criteria. Every gallery quietly evaluates before they ever schedule a studio visit, and how you can prepare yourself long before you send that portfolio email. Now let’s talk about why this matters. The gallery landscape has changed post 2020. Fewer staff, higher stakes, more pressure to show artists who will sell. But honestly, I think that’s always been true. Many artists submit too early with no positioning and no audience. Galleries take risks, but only calculated ones. They’re business people. So let’s decode the five things galleries are actually looking for in order, so you can stop guessing and start preparing.
Miriam Schulman: Here’s the truth galleries are small businesses making risk managed decisions. They don’t want to guess whether you’ll sell. They want proof. Number one sales history. Yes. This is the number one gallery representation requirement. If you want to understand how galleries really choose artists. This is the number one factor. Galleries want proof that your work already sells and that it will sell even without them? I know that sounds not fair, but they’re business people they want to know. Is there demand for this artist? Have collectors already voted with their wallets? If we put this on the wall, will it move? And listen, you do not need a six figure history, but you do need consistent sales. This is why Martha Brain is such a great example. She had a gallery and she was able to get two more just by sending out a A description about what her sales history is all about and what her art is. She knew right away that she could connect by being a business to business seller. She understood what galleries really are looking for. So sales history is the thing many artists ignore. They think that they can just show their art to a gallery, and if the gallery likes it, they’ll represent them. But really, galleries are looking for artists who have a sales history already. When we come back, I’m going to share the part artists really don’t want to hear. The role your audience plays in gallery selection.
Miriam Schulman: But first these words. Hey creatives, if you want 2026 to be your most focused and profitable year yet. Listen up. I’m hosting my annual goal setting workshop, the session that helps you map out revenue, projects, and clarity for the year ahead. It’s normally $97, but actually you can get it for free this month. And here’s how. All you have to do is buy a paperback copy of Artpreneur, the step by step guide to making a sustainable living from your creativity for yourself, or as a gift in December, and send us your receipt. And in case we haven’t met yet, I’m Miriam Schulman best selling author, 25 years as a professional artist and host of The Inspiration Place podcast. My students have generated hundreds of thousands of art sales using the system I teach. And in fact, this year we kept track and we sold over $400,000 worth of art in 2025. Now, if you want to join us so that 2026 is profitable for you to go to SchulmanArt.com/GOALS for the details and let’s build your 2026 on purpose. Criteria number two A preexisting audience. So this is kind of from the do galleries care about Instagram? Not really. It’s not the way you think. So here’s the truth galleries care far more about your email list, in other words, your collector list than they do about your Instagram. Instagram followers don’t equal buyers Instagram reach. It’s just not reliable. Instagram is an algorithm, not an audience. So the thing about Instagram is when I when I first wrote my book Artpreneur the average Instagram rate, when I first started writing it, it was 1%.
Miriam Schulman: And by the time I went to edit that chapter, it had dropped to 0.6%. And by 2025 last, we’re at the end of 2025, it dropped even more. It’s down to 0.3%, and the only reason it’s that high is because sports teams and universities have a 2% engagement rate. Retail, home decor, things like artists, it’s like 1.1%. So I’ve done the math. And even if you went with the average of a 0.36 engagement rate, you basically would need 6000 followers on Instagram to have the same results as 100 people on email. That’s why it’s so much easier to build a business with an email list. And that is also why gallery owners care more about your contact list. In other words, your email list than they do about Instagram. That’s not a contact list. You can’t contact everybody on there. Not everyone’s going to see it. There is a 40 times ROI on email as it is with social media and gallerists know this. So gallerists are now asking, can this artist bring collectors to an opening? Will their list help us drive sales not just for your art, but for the rest of the gallery? And are they known and trusted? This is why artists like Casey Lynn Hancock crush it. She sells high ticket art on LinkedIn because that’s where her people are.
Miriam Schulman: It’s not the size of the audience, it’s the responsiveness. So yes, when people ask, do galleries care about Instagram? The real answer is they care whether you can bring in buyers, not likes. Number three clarity of message and meaning. What are galleries are going to say so they can sell your work? This one is huge. If you can’t articulate what your art is about, the gallery won’t be able to sell it for you either. Collectors don’t buy paint on canvas or sculpture or metal. They buy story, they buy identity, they buy resonance. Meaning this is the story that they can repeat at dinner parties and galleries need messaging that’s clear, cohesive, repeatable, emotionally compelling. Think of artists like Bo, Sapphire or Bonnie Minardi. Their narratives are strong. A gallery can immediately understand what to say to collectors when they walk through the door. This is why, when artists ask me, what do galleries look for in artists? This is one of the biggest answers. Message clarity is non-negotiable. Non-negotiable. So if your message is weak, if it’s generic, if it’s boring, if it’s vanilla, if it sounds like everybody else, you’re going to have a lot of trouble getting gallery representation. Hey, artists, if you realize that maybe you’re too close your own art to explain it powerfully, you’re not alone. That’s exactly why I created the Artpreneur Messaging Intensive Plus Vault. It is a one on one session where we craft the exact words that you need to describe who you are, what you do, and why your art matters without sounding salesy, without sounding awkward, and definitely not generic.
Miriam Schulman: You’re going to walk away with a magnetic messaging vault customized just for you. You’ll walk away knowing how to explain what you do and why. You’ll walk away with emails that collectors actually want to read, and you’ll know exactly how to pitch. Galleries, the press, illustrators, manufacturers, whatever type of artist you are. It’s all about how to craft that story. This is not just another set of templates. It’s your truth translated and transmuted into words, words that connect and convert artists. Tell me it’s like you pulled this from my soul. Ready for a message that finally matches your art? To grab your spot, go to SchulmanArt.com/VAULT. Number four. Guess what? They have to like you. And I’m not talking about your art. They have to like you. Look, they don’t have to want to go on vacation with you. They don’t want to have to date you. But they do need to feel that your reliable, responsive. You meet deadlines, you communicate clearly, and you don’t create chaos. And yes, galleries will put up with jerks if the first three criteria are rock solid. So if somebody comes to them and they already have a six figure sales history, and they have an email list and they know they’re messaging. Those three are solid and they’re a little bit of a jerk or a little bit cuckoo.
Miriam Schulman: They’ll put up with it, but only if the first three are really, really good. But for the average artist, being a pleasure to work with will be a competitive advantage. This is the unspoken part that nobody wants to admit it loud. So you have to be reliable and you have to be nice. Now we’re on to number five. This is the last reason. And yes, they have to like your art, but this is the part that artists think is the only criteria and the number one criteria. But it’s actually the last thing on the list. This is number five on the list. This is where most artists start. But this is where galleries finish. So you need to have the first four in order to get that gallery appointment. Personal taste doesn’t matter as much as esthetic alignment is what they’re looking for, and curatorial fit is really going to matter. So if you are selling your art in Utah, which is very conservative, but your art is more of a Vegas vibe, you’re going to have to go there. So they’re looking for fit. They’re also looking for, do I already have this? So sometimes you could fit in too well, but they feel like they already have an artist that does what you do. Then they won’t be interested in you either. So it’s less about them liking your art personally, but more like understanding. Yeah, I know that kind of art will sell, even if maybe they don’t love it.
Miriam Schulman: Personally, that’s what they’re looking for. So that’s the uncomfortable truth. A gallery can love your art, but if it doesn’t fit in with their gallery, if you have no sales history, if you don’t have an audience, if you don’t have clarity about your work and don’t understand how to talk about it, or perhaps you’re difficult, they’re not taking you on. But let’s talk about the flip side, because there’s good news here. There’s a lot of things under your control. A gallery can feel neutral about your art, but if your audience, your sales, your message and your professionalism are strong, you’re in. That’s why understanding how galleries select artists is so empowering. It puts you back in control. Okay, so let’s go down the 32nd Gallery checklist. Here’s what every gallery is silently evaluating. Number one does this artist have a sales history. Number two Do they bring in a real audience? Number three, do they understand and communicate what their art means and why it matters? Number four are they easy to work with? Number five is the art a fit for our program? Now strengthen those up those four. And the last one is let’s remember it’s less about if they like it but whether it’s a fit. That means you just have to research the galleries. So you really are in control of pretty much everything. All right. Let’s wrap up with our final thoughts. Galleries don’t make artists successful.
Miriam Schulman: Prepared artists give galleries something to say yes to. So you don’t need to chase galleries, but you do need to build the foundations that galleries are looking for and that foundation is fully within your control. Now, before we wrap up, if you aren’t clear on your messaging, that’s what I specialize in helping you create magnetic messaging by excavating those stories and connecting all the dots from your life, from childhood to the present. I love this work. It’s absolutely amazing. Every single time I do one of these exercises with an artist, we’re always in awe of how all the puzzle pieces all fit together. And it makes sense. You’re an artist. It’s who you are. Everything about you is part of your art. So to get help from me, go to SchulmanArt.com/VAULT and let’s meet together and make sure your messaging is as strong as possible, so that when you approach a gallery, you’re ready to explain to them why your art matters. And if you’re not quite at that stage yet, you’ll be able to explain to prospective collectors what your art’s about in a way that resonates with them. Again, that’s SchulmanArt.com/VAULT. Now, again, if you love this episode, share it with an artist who’s been wondering why galleries aren’t accepting them as a client. Sometimes the truth is the most freeing thing you can hear. So this could be a gift you give them. And this always. I’ll see you next week. Same time, same place. Until then, stay inspired. Bye for now.
Speaker 2: Thank you for listening to the Inspiration Place podcast. Connect with us on Facebook, at Facebook.com/SchulmanArt And on Instagram at @SchulmanArt And of course, on SchulmanArt.com.
Subscribe & Review in iTunes
Are you subscribed to my podcast? If you’re not, I want to encourage you to do that today. I don’t want you to miss an episode. I’m adding a bunch of bonus episodes to the mix and if you’re not subscribed there’s a good chance you’ll miss out on those. Click here to subscribe in iTunes!
Now if you’re feeling extra loving, I would be really grateful if you left me a review over on iTunes, too. Those reviews help other people find my podcast and they’re also fun for me to go in and read. Just click here to review, select “Ratings and Reviews” and “Write a Review” and let me know what your favorite part of the podcast is. Thank you!